Analyzing Laverne Cox’s Transgendered Bodies and Cat Calling – Grey

Laverne Cox tells the story of how she was cat called on the street by two men and more importantly, the fear she felt as a transgendered women being hit on. Laverne states that these two men were involved in an argument over whether she was a “b word” (female) or an “n word” (male). This argument reveals the focus society places on transgendered bodies, and the violence transgendered people face when it is realized that they had male or female genitalia before. Laverne Cox’s story illustrates the intersections of transphobia and racialization of bodies.

In media transgendered people are depicted in a negative manner the majority of the time (GLAAD). Transphobia is the hate of transgendered people, and it is taught to society through media depictions. Julia Serano identifies two archetypes typically assigned to transsexuals: the deceptive transsexual and the pathetic transsexual (Serano, 2005). While pathetic transsexual depictions hurts the image of transsexuals in mainstream culture, the deceptive transsexuals incites violence against transgendered bodies. Deceptive transsexuals trick men into a sexual relationship before revealing that they have, or had, male genitalia. Men in these movies often retaliate by raping or physically assaulting the transsexual (Serano, 2005). Therefore, one notices a socialization of violence against transgendered bodies. Media socialization of violence against transgendered bodies has been successful, albeit accidentally. In the LGBTQ community, transgendered people account for fifty-four percent of all homicides (Cox, 2014).

Media depictions further transphobia with their emphasis on transgendered bodies. Transgendered bodies are typically feminized, showing the feminine aspects of Male-to-Female (MTF) transitions. For example, an Oprah special Normal sought to improve on transgendered depictions in the media; however, the show had a femme fascination (Serano, 2005). Instead of showing transgendered bodies as “normal,” the show mainly focused on the feminization of trans-women showing their underwear, makeup, and fashion (Serano, 2005). The femme fascination the media holds demonstrates male privilege. Male sexuality is not explored to the same extent as female sexuality. Moreover, in Cox’s story she mentions how she was never hit on before her surgery (Cox, 2014). Therefore, being a male does hold the same importance on being sexual as a female body.

Transphobia and the racialization of bodies intersect in Cox’s piece, illustrating the ingrained racism in society. Firstly, racialization is the process of sexualizing racial bodies and objectifying persons of colours’ bodies. In Gendered Worlds, authors Aulette and Wittner provide examples of black women being sexualized as: “…selfish or that of foolish victims” (108). In Cox’s own tale, she was made out to be the “foolish victim,” as both men cat called and degraded her.

Secondly, Aulette and Wittner mention that black men in the media are also hypersexualized and are portrayed as “…brutish and aggressive…” (107). One can see this image being perpetuated in Cox’s piece. The men believe that in order to sleep with a black woman, they must be aggressive and brutish. Instead of simply approaching Cox, they felt they had to degrade her and behave aggressively, to the point where Cox feared for her life. This ideal is further perpetuated by the media assigning the behaviour of womanizers (Tiger Woods, Magic Johnson etc.) to black people as a whole. Therefore, these young men felt they had to aspire to the image set out by the media and, in order to achieve this, they must be aggressive towards Cox.

Finally, the racialization of transphobia intersects with white privilege. As Cox states, “…I’ve talked to a lot of white trans women who haven’t experienced quite the level of street harassment that I have” (Cox, 2014). White privilege is experienced among transgendered bodies. Cox explains that by being white one will experience less racialization of their body, and illustrates Peggy McIntosh’s piece on the invisibility of whiteness. One would assume that becoming transsexual would result in discrimination, but that is clearly not the case. White privilege is present even with transgendered bodies, and white privilege still works to their benefit.

Just as white privilege, racialization, and transphobia are invisibly socialized in Western society, so is violence against transgendered people. Cornel West states that justice is what love looks like in public; therefore, there can be no such thing as justice if transgendered people live in fear of violence. Laverne Cox shares her experience as a transgendered woman in New York City, and while her experience is not unique, her fear of being murdered because of her body is unique to the trans community. If transgendered people live in fear of being murdered for having genitalia which differs from what society deems appropriate, there is no such thing as justice. Just as transphobia and racialization intersect, so do justice and public opinion, to obtain justice one must be widely accepted by the public.

Bibliography

Aulette, Judy R., and Judith Wittner. “Chapter 4: Sexualities.” Gendered Worlds. 3rd ed. New York: Oxford UP, 2015. Print.

“Laverne Cox Explains the Intersection of Transphobia, Racism, and Misogyny (And What to             Do About It).” everydayfeminism. Cox, Laverne, 7 Dec. 2014. Web. 6 Mar. 2015.

“Victims or Villains: Examining Ten Years of Transgender Images on Television.” GLAAD.             GLAAD, n.d. Web. 8 Mar. 2015.

Serano, Julia. “Skirt Chasers: Why the Media Depicts the Trans Revolution in Lipstick and Heels.” On the Outside Looking In. Oakland: Hot Tranny Action Press, 2005. Web. .

Advertisements
Analyzing Laverne Cox’s Transgendered Bodies and Cat Calling – Grey

8 thoughts on “Analyzing Laverne Cox’s Transgendered Bodies and Cat Calling – Grey

  1. Grey,
    Your blog post was great! I liked that the course terms were used cohesively and throughout the post. I also enjoyed the fact that you had a great amount of outside resources (ex. White Privilege article, the Julia Serano article, etc) and how you used those to articulate your argument. I lastly liked the fact that you used pop culture to relate back to transphobia and racialization to show that the issue is still current and successfully related these issues back to the video of Laverne Cox. If there were any critique, perhaps cutting down your paragraphs and making them precise so that your blog doesn’t have to be as long.
    Overall, blessed work! #teamcheckurprivilege
    -Purple

    Like

  2. Grey,
    Great review!! Your summary was quick, but remained to the point and provided an in-depth analysis of the original article with a small amount of space. Your use of an outside source was very well integrated into your piece, especially as it was written by an author we have visited previously before. You demonstrate a strong understanding of Serano’s archetypes, and prove it within your explanations of the terms. The use of statistics create more of a concrete footing for your arguments, making them stronger. I also noticed the input of the idea of male privilege, and this was a new insight for me as I, personally, never looked at it with that idea. You also demonstrate a strong analysis of black men being hypersexualized in the media, with a good connection to specific celebrities. Lastly, your ideas surrounding the intersection with white privilege and the element of white trans-women provide the strong conclusion that this review clearly has. Once again, good job!
    -Red

    Like

  3. Grey,
    Good blog. You had a very strong use of the term “socialization”, creating a nice connection to transgender individuals and transgender violence. Some critiques for you would be that you had a rather abrupt introduction paragraph, I would suggest that you should have introduced your topic and viewpoint on the matter first, before introducing the article. Also, I would have liked you to expand on your statement that “being a male does hold the same importance on being sexual as a female body”. What exactly do you mean by this? Why is it relevant?

    -Green

    Like

    1. Thanks Green! My intro did end very abruptly, and I think I could have expanded more on Cox’s ideas or opinions.
      My comment on “being a male does hold the same importance on being sexual as a female body,” was looking at male privilege. How the female body, in regards to transgendered people, holds a bigger significance on being “pretty” or “feminine”.

      -Grey

      Like

  4. I thought this blog was great! You did a good job of summarizing the video on Laverne Cox, giving the reader enough and the most important information on the topic. You demonstrate a great understanding of the issue and incorporated some great terms and articles to help strengthen your argument. I liked the way you displayed how transphobia and racialization of people are intersected, as well as including the influence of white privilege. Also, adding the statistics helped create a greater sense of the violence transgendered people face. You gave some good examples from pop culture and tied everything together nicely. One criticism would be to have an opening that presents what your blog is focusing on, rather than starting with a summary, to better engage the reader. What is your opinion on the issue and what can we do to create a more welcoming environment for transgendered people?
    -Blue

    Like

    1. Thanks Blue. The intro was very disengaged, and definitely not my best writing.
      My opinion on the issue is that transgendered people have been heavily stigmatized against by both mainstream culture (heteronormative) and LGBT culture. I think the way to fix this is to: a) work on transgendered depictions in media (looking at Serano’s ideas) and b) to ally more groups (both disadvantaged and advantaged) with transgendered groups. Bringing transgendered people more into mainstream culture and acceptance.

      What is your opinion?

      -Grey

      Like

  5. I agree with your opinion, and think that is very well written. This is a great idea and shows your understanding of the topic. I think society as a whole should work together to help resolve this issue. Whether you are transgendered or not, to truly rid of the stigma, we all have to be involved in this movement.
    -Blue

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s